What is AI therapy? How to talk to AI for best outcomes?

AI therapy is a relatively new concept in the world of mental health, and it can sometimes be misunderstood. When people hear “AI therapy,” they might imagine a future where human therapists are replaced by cold, clinical robots that lack empathy and intuition. But the truth is more nuanced: AI therapy isn’t about replacing human therapists, but rather supplementing or supporting therapeutic processes with technology in ways that make mental health care more accessible, consistent, and available around the clock.

Let’s break this down by looking at some key distinctions and practical applications, as well as the evidence on its effectiveness.

1. The Difference Between an AI Tool and a Human Therapist

AI therapy is fundamentally different from traditional therapy because it lacks true human consciousness, subjective experience, and emotional depth. A human therapist can offer empathy, non-verbal cues, and nuanced understanding—qualities that are difficult, if not impossible, for AI to replicate in full. However, where AI falls short in subjective human experience, it gains in terms of being a consistent, unbiased, and 24/7 accessible tool.

Here’s an interesting way to frame it: a human therapist is a partner in the therapeutic process, but an AI tool is more of a facilitator. When using AI for mental health support, the person seeking help remains in the driver’s seat to a much greater extent. They have to be actively involved, prompting the AI, directing their own reflections, and deciding what to make of the responses they receive. This self-directed nature can actually empower some people who feel a need for more autonomy in their healing process, or who might be intimidated by the more formal, vulnerable dynamic of face-to-face therapy.

Think of it as the difference between talking to a close friend (human therapist) and using a reflective journal (AI tool). The friend listens, validates, challenges, and responds to your energy and expressions. A journal, on the other hand, doesn’t judge or offer opinions but gives you a structured way to think things through. AI therapy tools fall somewhere in between—more interactive than a journal, but without the depth and empathy of a human friend or therapist.

One benefit here is accessibility. AI can provide support for people in places where mental health services are scarce or prohibitively expensive. It’s available on-demand, which can be crucial for people dealing with episodic issues like panic attacks or sleepless nights.

2. Concrete Examples of How to Prompt Effectively

If you’re using an AI therapy tool, knowing how to “talk” to it can make a big difference in the quality of support you get. Most AI tools work by using prompts or guiding questions, and the way you frame your prompts can guide the AI in delivering a more helpful response.

Here are some practical tips for effective prompting:

• Be Specific About What You’re Feeling or Thinking. Rather than saying, “I feel bad,” try to describe your experience more specifically, like “I feel anxious about an upcoming presentation at work.” This gives the AI a better framework to work with and can result in responses that are more targeted and useful.
• Ask for Specific Types of Help. If you want the AI to help you reframe a negative thought, ask it directly. For example, “Can you help me think about this problem from a different perspective?” or “What’s a way to challenge the thought that I’m not good enough?” These kinds of questions can lead the AI to generate cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)-based responses, which are often part of the design in AI therapy tools.
• Use it to Track Patterns Over Time. Many AI therapy tools allow you to review past interactions. This can be useful for identifying recurring thought patterns or triggers that come up again and again. When you ask things like “Why do I keep feeling this way on Sundays?” or “Is there a pattern to my low moods?” you can start to piece together insights from repeated interactions.
• Ask for Specific Strategies or Techniques. Many AI tools are designed to provide evidence-based techniques, like breathing exercises, grounding techniques, or gratitude practices. If you’re feeling overwhelmed, you might ask, “Can you guide me through a relaxation exercise?” or “What are some ways I can reduce my stress in this moment?”

By prompting effectively, users can maximize the value of AI therapy tools, using them as a resource to explore their feelings, challenge their thoughts, and learn practical coping mechanisms.

3. Evidence Supporting the Effectiveness of AI Therapy

So, does it work? While AI therapy is still a new field, there’s a growing body of evidence suggesting that it can be effective, especially for certain types of mental health support. Here are a few key findings:

• Symptom Reduction in Anxiety and Depression. Some studies have found that AI-based therapy apps, particularly those using CBT techniques, can be effective in reducing symptoms of anxiety and depression (Fitzpatrick, Darcy & Vierhile, 2017). For example, a randomized controlled trial published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research found that participants who used an AI-powered CBT app showed significant reductions in anxiety and depression compared to a control group.
• Consistency and Availability Lead to Better Outcomes. One of the biggest benefits of AI therapy tools is their availability. Many people find that they benefit from being able to log on and “talk” whenever they need to, without waiting for a scheduled appointment. This can be especially helpful for people dealing with unpredictable or episodic mental health issues. Studies have shown that individuals who use AI therapy tools consistently over time (even just a few times a week) often report better outcomes than those who engage sporadically, because the constant availability encourages regular self-reflection and skill-building (Ly, Ly & Andersson, 2017).
• Non-Judgmental Environment Reduces Barriers to Entry. Research has shown that some people are hesitant to seek therapy because of stigma or fear of judgment (Lucas et al., 2014). AI tools provide a non-judgmental environment that may encourage individuals to open up and reflect more freely than they would with a human. In fact, some users report that AI tools help them articulate thoughts and feelings they might be embarrassed to express to another person, which can be a valuable stepping stone towards seeking further help.

However, it’s important to recognize that the effectiveness of AI therapy has limitations. For severe mental health issues, like major depression, bipolar disorder, or PTSD, human therapists are crucial because they bring clinical expertise, nuanced judgment, and a therapeutic alliance that AI cannot replicate. AI therapy, in these cases, may serve as a supplementary tool, but not as a standalone solution.

Wrapping Up: How AI Therapy Can Support Your Growth

In summary, AI therapy tools offer a unique way for people to engage in self-reflection and develop coping strategies in a way that’s accessible, affordable, and autonomous. They won’t replace human therapists anytime soon, nor should they; instead, they offer a new dimension of support, one that might be particularly valuable for people who want help with daily stress, anxiety, or mild depressive symptoms.

If you’re interested in trying AI-assisted therapy, you might want to download the MindForest App (https://mindforest.ai). This app is designed not just as a mental health tool, but as a personal growth coach. By using psychology-based prompts, guided reflections, and interactive exercises, MindForest can help you explore your thoughts, develop emotional resilience, and build practical skills that support well-being. Whether you’re dealing with anxiety, struggling to stay motivated, or just looking to understand yourself better, MindForest can provide a structured, supportive environment to guide your journey.

Give it a try—AI therapy could be the first step towards deeper self-awareness and sustainable personal growth.

‍

References
‍

Fitzpatrick, K. K., Darcy, A., & Vierhile, M. (2017). Delivering cognitive behavior therapy to young adults with symptoms of depression and anxiety using a fully automated conversational agent (Woebot): a randomized controlled trial. JMIR mental health, 4(2), e7785.

Ly, K. H., Ly, A. M., & Andersson, G. (2017). A fully automated conversational agent for promoting mental well-being: a pilot RCT using mixed methods. Internet interventions, 10, 39-46.

Lucas, G. M., Gratch, J., King, A., & Morency, L. P. (2014). It’s only a computer: Virtual humans increase willingness to disclose. Computers in Human Behavior, 37, 94-100.